Anti-leprosy protective vaccination of rhesus monkeys with BCG or BCG plus heat-killed Mycobacterium leprae: lepromin skin test results.

Groups of rhesus monkeys (RM) were vaccinated and boosted with living Mycobacterium bovis Bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) or BCG + low dose (LD) heat-killed Mycobacterium leprae (HKML) or high dose (HD) HKML or were unvaccinated. Animals vaccinated with BCG + LD and HD HKML were lepromin skin tested 2 weeks after boosting. All groups were lepromin tested 37 and 46 months after challenge with live M. leprae. Fernandez (72 h) and Mitsuda (28 day) responses were recorded. Ten of 10 rhesus monkeys in each of the two BCG + HKML-vaccinated groups significantly converted to strong positive Fernandez status within 2 weeks of boosting, compared to one of six positives in the unvaccinated unchallenged normal control group. Both BCG + HKML groups were significantly protected from clinical leprosy. Six of 10 in each of the two BCG + HKML groups significantly converted to Mitsuda positivity within 2 weeks of boosting compared to zero of six in the normal control group. The sizes of the Mitsuda responses were larger in the LD group than the HD HKML vaccinated/boosted group, suggesting suppression by vaccination with higher doses of HKML in combination with BCG. Fernandez responses were negative in normal RM as well as in the unvaccinated, ML-challenged group and the BCG-vaccinated, ML-challenged group at 37 or 46 months after ML inoculation, although the BCG-vaccinated group was significantly protected from leprosy and the unvaccinated group was not. In contrast, at 37 months the Fernandez reaction was positive in the BCG plus LD and the BCG plus HD HKML-vaccinated groups, both of which were significantly protected from clinical leprosy. By 46 months, the Fernandez responses were below significance in all groups. Thus, Fernandez reactivity is not a reliable correlate to protection from experimental leprosy in RM. Mitsuda responses became strongly positive in all four ML-challenged groups by 37 months and remained strongly positive at 46 months after ML inoculation, suggesting that strong Mitsuda reactivity reflects responses to living ML. BCG or BCG + LD or HD HKML vaccination/boosting of RM produced significant clinical protection from leprosy and there was a good correlation between protection from LL forms of leprosy and positive Mitsuda skin test responses after challenge with live ML. Positive Mitsuda responses were generated in essentially all individuals after challenge with live ML, and this response was primed by prior vaccination/boosting with BCG + HKML as shown by conversion to positivity 2 weeks after boosting. The data show that resistance to clinical leprosy is reflected by Mitsuda responses in ML-exposed RM, similar to results from human studies, and confirm the suitability of RM as a model for leprosy vaccine studies.

Interactions between Mycobacterium leprae and simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) in rhesus monkeys.

Groups of rhesus monkeys were inoculated with: 1) simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV)B670 alone; 2) Mycobacterium leprae alone; 3) SIV plus M. leprae on the same day; and 4) M. leprae 2 weeks after SIV. Animals were monitored at intervals for virus loads, antibody responses to M. leprae glycolipid antigens and to SIV Gp120, T-cell CD4+ and CD4+ CD29+ subset percentages, leprosy and acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) clinical symptoms. Five out of six animals developed leprosy in each co-inoculated group, compared to one out of six in the M. leprae-only-inoculated group, indicating that M. leprae/SIV co-infection increases the susceptibility to leprosy, regardless of the timing of the two infections. Animals in the co-infected group that received M. leprae 2 weeks after SIV had a significantly slower rate of AIDS progression and long-term survival was significantly greater (three out of six) compared to the group inoculated with SIV alone (zero out of seven). All M. leprae-only-inoculated animals (six out of six) survived. Post-SIV-inoculation, a rapid decrease in the percentages of CD4 + and CD4 + CD29 + T-cells was observed in the SIV-only-inoculated group that was significantly blocked by co-inoculation with M. leprae 2 weeks after SIV, but not by SIV on the same day. The virus load set point was increased by approximately two logs in the group inoculated with M. leprae and SIV on the same day compared to SIV 2 weeks prior to M. leprae or the SIV-only-inoculated group. The results indicate that M. leprae, inoculated 2 weeks after SIV, decreased the pathogenicity of SIV compared to inoculation of M. leprae and SIV on the same day or SIV alone. The decreased pathogenicity correlated with a diminished loss of CD4 + and CD4 + CD29 + T-cell subsets in the group inoculated with M. leprae 2 weeks after SIV compared to the group inoculated with SIV alone. IgG antibody responses to M. leprae-specific cell wall phenolic glycolipid-I antigen were inhibited by 2-week-prior or same-day SIV co-inoculation compared to M. leprae-only inoculated animals. The IgG anti-lipoarabinomannan antibody response was enhanced in the group inoculated with M. leprae and SIV on the same day compared to the groups inoculated with M. leprae alone or SIV 2 weeks prior to M. leprae. Antibody responses to SIV Gp120 antigen were unimpaired in both co-inoculated groups compared to SIV-only-inoculated groups. The antibody results show that the immune responses to SIV and M. leprae are interrelated in SIV/M. leprae co-infected animals.

Antileprosy protective vaccination of rhesus monkeys with BCG or BCG plus heat-killed Mycobacterium leprae: immunologic observations.

Groups of rhesus monkeys were vaccinated and boosted with Mycobacterium bovis bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) or BCG plus low-dose (LD) or high-dose (HD) heat-killed M. leprae (HKML), or were unvaccinated. Prior to and following vaccination-boosting and subsequent M. leprae (ML) challenge, these and unvaccinated, unchallenged control monkeys were observed longitudinally for approximately 3 years. Vaccination with BCG plus HKML initially stimulated significant in vitro blood mononuclear cell blastogenic responses to lepromin, which returned to baseline post-boosting and post-live-ML-challenge, minimally reappearing significantly 2 years post-ML-challenge. Vaccination with BCG failed to stimulated positive blastogenic responses to lepromin before ML-challenge but small, marginally positive, intermittent responses were seen post-ML-challenge. Compared to the unvaccinated ML-challenged group, significant increases in the numbers of blood CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell subsets and an increased CD4+:CD8+ ratio were observed in both BCG plus HKML-vaccinated, ML-challenged groups, but not in the BCG-only-vaccinated, ML-challenged group. CD4+CD29+ and CD4+CD45RA+ subset numbers increased significantly over time in only the BCG plus LD HKML-vaccinated, ML-challenged group. Compared to unvaccinated, ML-challenged groups, vaccination with BCG or BCG plus HKML followed by ML-challenge produced lower IgM:IgG antiphenolic glycolipid-I (PGL-I) serum antibody ratios and protected rhesus monkeys from clinical leprosy, consistent with prior observations that low IgM:IgG anti-PGL-I responses correlated with resistance to and protection from leprosy.

Antileprosy protective vaccination of sooty mangabey monkeys with BCG or BCG plus heat-killed Mycobacterium leprae: immunologic observations.

Groups of sooty mangabey monkeys (SMM) were vaccinated and boosted with Mycobacterium bovis bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG), or BCG + low-dose (LD) or high-dose (HD) heat-killed M. leprae (HKML), or were unvaccinated. Prior to and following vaccination-boosting and subsequent M. leprae (ML) challenge, these and unvaccinated, unchallenged control monkeys were immunologically observed longitudinally for approximately 3 years. SMM [multibacillary (MB) leprosy-prone as a species] were not protected clinically by BCG or BCG + HKML, although the disease progress was slowed by vaccination with BCG alone. The longitudinal immune response profiles to BCG or BCG + HKML in SMM showed that: 1) vaccination with BCG or BCG + HKML initially stimulated significant in vitro blood mononuclear cell blastogenic responses to ML antigens, which returned to baseline post-boosting and post-live ML challenge; 2) BCG + LD HKML-vaccinated groups gave the largest blastongenic response (SI = 23) followed by the BCG + HD HKML group (SI = 14.5) and by the BCG-only vaccinated group (SI = 3.6); 3) significantly diminished numbers of blood CD4+ (helper) and CD4+CD29+ (helper-inducer) T-cell subsets were observed longitudinally in all ML-challenged groups compared to controls regardless of whether they had been vaccinated or not; 4) CD8+ (suppressor) T-cell numbers remained longitudinally constant, on average, in all ML-challenged groups (vaccinated or not) compared to controls; 5) there was a significant decrease in the CD4+:CD8+ ratio over time in all ML-challenged groups (vaccinated or not); 6) vaccination with BCG or BCG + LD or HD HKML resulted in significantly increased numbers of CD4+CD45RA+ (suppressor-inducer) T cells longitudinally compared to the unvaccinated, ML-challenged control group; and 7) over time, vaccination with BCG + HKML followed by live ML-challenge produced higher IGM:IgG antiphenolic glycolipid-I (PGL-I) serum antibody response ratios than BCG-only vaccinated, ML-challenged monkeys or unvaccinated, ML-challenged SMM, consistent with prior observations that IgG anti-PGL-I responses correlate with resistance to and protection from clinical leprosy and IgM anti-PGL-I responses correlate with increased susceptibility.

Experimental leprosy in rhesus monkeys: transmission, susceptibility, clinical and immunological findings.

A total of 46 Rhesus monkeys (RM) was inoculated with Mycobacterium leprae (ML) and followed clinically and immunologically for extended periods. Twenty-one (45.7%) of the RM developed leprosy spanning the known leprosy spectrum, with six of 21 (28.6%) having disease in the borderline lepromatous to lepromatous area of the spectrum. RM with paucibacillary forms of leprosy produced predominantly IgG anti-phenolic glycolipid (PGL-I) antibodies and positive lepromin skin test and/or in vitro blastogenesis responses; IgM anti-PGL-I predominated in animals with BB-LL leprosy and correlated with negative immune responses to lepromin. IgG anti-PGL-I antibodies persisted in a number of RM for several years without histopathological evidence of leprosy, suggesting possible persisting subclinical infection. The data show that RM are a valuable model for the study of leprosy. Eleven of the 46 RM were inoculated with ML from sources infected with simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV), the monkey counterpart to the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). The possible effect of SIV on the clinical outcome of ML infection could not be determined due to insufficient numbers of animals to yield statistically significant results.

Spontaneous leprosy in a wild-caught cynomolgus macaque.

Naturally occurring Mycobacterium leprae has been previously documented in only two species of nonhuman primates from West Africa--the chimpanzee and the sooty mangabey. We report here the first known case of spontaneous leprosy in an Asian macaque. A wild-caught cynomolgus macaque imported from The Philippines developed a reaction to a tuberculin skin test after 3 years at the California Regional Primate Research Center (CRPRC), University of California-Davis, Davis, California, U.S.A. Biopsies of concurrent skin lesions suggested a cutaneous mycobacterial infection. Diagnosis of the infection was obtained by a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay specific for M. leprae. Clinical presentation, histopathological findings, and ELISA serology for M. leprae-specific PGL-I and to the LAM mycobacterial antigens were consistent with those of human borderline (BB) leprosy. Longitudinal serologic data suggest that the cynomolgus macaque had subclinical leprosy at the time of arrival in the CRPRC quarantine. Intradermal tuberculin testing is the traditional method for screening nonhuman primate populations for mycobacterial infections. Exposure to nontuberculous mycobacteria, such as M. leprae, amy sensitize some individual primates to nonspecific mycobacterial antigens, resulting in false-positive tuberculin reactions. Susceptibility of the cynomolgus macaque and other nonhuman primates to M. leprae should be re-evaluated. Cynomolgus macaques and, possibly, other nonhuman primates may serve as valuable experimental models of leprosy in humans.

Protective immunization of monkeys with BCG or BCG plus heat-killed Mycobacterium leprae: clinical results.

Rhesus and sooty mangabey monkeys (RM and SMM) were vaccinated and boosted with BCG or BCG + low dose (LD) or high dose (HD) heat-killed Mycobacterium leprae (HKML). One group was not vaccinated. Except for a group of controls, all monkeys were challenged with live M. leprae. All animals were studied longitudinally to determine antileprosy protective efficacy. BCG reduced the numbers of RM with histopathologically-diagnosed leprosy by 70% and slowed and ameliorated the appearance of symptoms. BCG + LDHKML reduced the number of RM with leprosy by 89% and BCG + HDHKML by 78%. BCG did not protect SMM from developing leprosy, but disease progress was slowed; disease in SMM was exacerbated by the addition of HKML to the vaccine. RM, as a species, are prone to paucibacillary (PB) forms of leprosy, whereas SMM are prone to multibacillary (MB) forms. Thus, BCG vaccination offers significant protection from clinical disease and slows/ameliorates the rate of progression/degree of disease at the PB end and appears to at least ameliorate symptoms at the MB end of the leprosy spectrum. BCG + HKML protects at the PB end and exacerbates disease progress at the MB end of the leprosy spectrum.

Impaired responses to Mycobacterium leprae antigens in rhesus monkeys experimentally inoculated with simian immunodeficiency virus and M. leprae.

Seven of eight rhesus monkeys (RM) coinfected with simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) and Mycobacterium leprae harboured acid-fast bacilli (AFB) at sites of dermal inoculation and/or at disseminated sites at times of humane sacrifice (up to 270 days post-M. leprae inoculation) due to SIV-induced debilitation or, in one long term survivor's case, to date over 3 years post-M. leprae inoculation. Detectable AFB were cleared in biopsies of inoculation sites of RM inoculated with M. leprae alone after 63 days postinoculation; these sites have, so far, remained AFB-negative, thereafter. Compared to animals infected with M. leprae alone, RM coinfected with SIV plus M. leprae showed: 1, completely suppressed serum antibody responses to M. leprae-specific PGL-I antigen, but strong anti-SIV Gp120 antibody responses; 2, impaired sensitization of blood mononuclear cells (MNC) to in vitro recognition of M. leprae-specific antigens in blastogenic stimulation assays; 3, impaired in vitro responses of blood MNC to nonspecific (ConA) blastogenic stimuli; and 4, early post-M. leprae inoculation, there was a significant incremental diminution of percentages of blood CD4+CD29+ T-cells in addition to the existing SIV-induced diminished percentages of CD4+CD29+ T-cells. The results indicate that humoral and cellular immune responses to M. leprae antigens are compromised in M. leprae-inoculated RM previously infected with SIV. These results provide an immunologic basis for the demonstration of enhanced M. leprae persistence or leprosy susceptibility in SIV-M. leprae coinfected RM.

Detection of IgA anti-PGL-I specific antigen to Mycobacterium leprae in mangabey monkeys inoculated with M. leprae.

Using sera from 4 pairs of mangabey monkeys inoculated with titrated doses of Mycobacterium leprae we demonstrated that IgA antibodies against M. leprae specific PGL-I antigen were present in 75% of inoculated monkey's sera. High IgA antibody was detected in 50% (3/6) of infected animals and all three developed lepromatous leprosy (LL). Antibody titers correlated with PGL-I antigen in serum. The highest IgA peak appeared late and corresponded to the beginning of treatment, and in two of them appeared shortly after or corresponded with neurological damage. Low IgA response was found in the other 3 monkeys (50%-3/6), two of which developed indeterminate leprosy (I) and the other one LL. Low IgA levels appeared late after IgG and IgM, and shortly after neurologic signs. Both I monkeys were negative for PGL-I in serum. The remaining 2 monkeys (25%-2/8) did not show an IgA response; one of them developed LL but the disease regressed to I. IgM seemed to correspond to the appearance of PGL-I in serum. The other animal did not develop clinical symptoms of leprosy, and PGL-I in serum was negative. Although there was no clear relation between the development of anti-PGL-I IgA and experimental leprosy, the finding of a high IgA response in some animals suggests that further studies are needed to evaluate the role of antigen-specific IgA in the disease process.

Experimental leprosy in monkeys. II. Longitudinal serological observations in sooty mangabey monkeys.

In this study, 11 SMM were grouped and inoculated with differing doses of SMM-origin Mycobacterium leprae (ML) between 4.5 x 10(8) and 1 x 10(9) by either combined IV/IC routes or by IV or IC route alone. The combined route was the most effective in eliciting progressive, disseminated LL leprosy. In all, 6 of 7 SMM inoculated by the combined routes developed leprosy requiring treatment at some point. Only 1 of 4 inoculated by a single route developed persisting leprosy requiring chemotherapy. Either no disease or spontaneous regression of initial disease occurred in the other 3 animals inoculated by a single route. Doses in excess of 1 x 10(9) ML were more effective than lesser doses. An association was observed between the development of IgG anti-PGL-I ELISA OD values and resistance to leprosy and between IgM anti-PGL-I and leprosy progression or susceptibility. Serum PGL-I antigen levels, determined by dot ELISA, paralleled disease severity longitudinally. High positive OD values of anti-LAM IgG prior to ML inoculation were observed in the majority of leprosy-susceptible SMM in contrast to negative levels in more resistant animals. Anti-LAM IgG OD values exceeded the positive cut-off point after inoculation in 5 of 11 SMM; 3 of these 5 had concurrent detectable serum levels of PGL-I antigen.

Experimental leprosy in monkeys. I. Sooty mangabey monkeys: transmission, susceptibility, clinical and pathological findings.

A total of 31 sooty mangabey monkeys (SMM) (Cercocebus torquatus atys) inoculated by various routes with differing numbers of SMM-origin Mycobacterium leprae (ML) and 4 SMM inoculated with human-origin ML were observed for 4-12 years. SMM-origin ML was more pathogenic in SMM than human-origin ML. The spectrum of disease ranged from indeterminate to borderline and lepromatous in different animals. Some animals developed pure neural leprosy. Erythema nodosum leprosum (SNL) was also observed. Combined intravenous/intracutaneous (IV/IC) routes of inoculation more effectively induced advancing, disseminated lepromatous forms of leprosy; IV or IC routes alone were less effective at comparable doses. Total IV/IC doses of SMM-origin ML equal to or greater than 5 x 10(8), with morphologic indices (MIs) ranging from 5 to 10%, produced advancing, disseminated LL leprosy in 92% of SMM. Lower IV/IC doses and inoculations by a single IV or IC route produced fewer leprosy infections and more spontaneous regressions. As a species, captive SMM are highly susceptible to experimental leprosy and provide an excellent model for the longitudinal study of leprosy.

Serologic responses to nerve antigens in sooty mangabey monkeys with experimental leprosy.

Eight sooty mangabey monkeys were inoculated intravenously and intradermally with varying doses of Mycobacterium leprae from 4.8 x 10(7) to 4.8 x 10(10). Serum samples were obtained from the animals at intervals of about 3 months for 90 months, and were examined for IgM and IgG antibodies to nerve antigens, including ceramide, galactocerebroside (GC), and asialo-GM1 (AGM1), using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The serological results were then compared with clinical findings, particularly nerve involvement. Of 8 mangabey monkeys inoculated with M. leprae, 7 animals had clinical leprosy; 6 of them had nerve damage, including neurologic deformities in 4 monkeys and nerve enlargement in 2. Median time for the initial signs of leprosy was 10 months postinoculation (p.i.), a range from 4 to 35 months. In contrast, nerve damage was noted rather late, about 35 to 86 months p.i. (median 54 months). The major immunoglobulin class to ceramide, GC, and AGM1 antigens was IgM, and the antibody responses to the nerve antigens appeared from 15 to 63 months p.i. (median 37 months). Antineural antibodies were thus detectable about 18 months (range -2 to 60 months) prior to observable nerve damage. In addition, elevation of antineural antibody levels were predictive of clinical exacerbation of the disease and neuritic damage. This study suggests that antineural antibodies are produced during the course of M. leprae infection and may be indicative of nerve damage, such as neurological deformities or nerve enlargement, in leprosy patients.

Nonhuman sources of leprosy.

Our findings establish that there are known extrahuman reservoirs of M. leprae in three animal species. There is considerable evidence that the armadillo plays a role in the epidemiology of leprosy in humans in Texas and Louisiana. The elimination of leprosy as a public health problem (defined by the World Health Organization as one active patient per 10,000 population) may be attainable by the wide application of current control measures; however, the ultimate eradication of leprosy must take into account extrahuman reservoirs of M. leprae. The impact that attempts to control or to eliminate leprosy in such reservoirs (e.g., the armadillo in Louisiana and Texas) would have on environmental and wild-life considerations would be profound. Whether or not similar situations prevail in other leprosy-endemic geographic areas is not known. Based on the armadillo experience, there seems to be ample justification for undertaking, forthwith, carefully designed surveys for enzootic leprosy in some of the major endemic areas of leprosy. At the current state of our knowledge of the subject, such surveys should be initiated in the natural habitats of the mangabey monkey and chimpanzees--in West Africa.

Experimental borderline lepromatous leprosy with intraneural erythema nodosum leprosum in a mangabey monkey (Cercocebus atys).

A sooty mangabey monkey (Cercocebus atys) was inoculated with Mycobacterium leprae and developed borderline lepromatous leprosy and intraneural erythema nodosum leprosum. Previously studied mangabeys have developed only disseminated lepromatous leprosy without reactions. This case broadens the spectrum of leprosy seen in experimentally inoculated animals and further characterizes the nonhuman primate model of leprosy.

A serologic study of naturally acquired leprosy in chimpanzees.

Data from longitudinally obtained serum samples spanning several years has permitted us to identify two chimpanzees with leprosy and to estimate the time of Mycobacterium leprae exposure/infection. The results confirm high levels of specific anti-M. leprae phenolic glycolipid-I (PGL-I) as well as anti-lipo-arabinomannan (anti-LAM) antibodies in both chimpanzees, and identify additional chimpanzees with possible M. leprae exposure. The observations are consistent with the hypothesis that leprosy exists in chimpanzees in the U.S.A. and suggest the possibility that M. leprae may be transmitted among chimpanzees. The data suggest that monitoring anti-PGL-I and anti-LAM IgG and IgM levels longitudinally in leprosy contacts may be useful in the recognition of preclinical leprosy.

Naturally acquired and experimental leprosy in nonhuman primates.

Naturally-acquired leprosy has been observed in chimpanzees and sooty mangabey monkeys. Experimental multibacillary leprosy was established in 24 of 36 mangabey monkeys, 7 of 34 rhesus monkeys, and 15 of 19 African green monkeys following intravenous and intradermal inoculation of Mycobacterium leprae. The experimental disease strongly resembles leprosy in humans clinically, histopathologically, and immunologically. Thus, in addition to nine-banded armadillos in Louisiana and Texas, chimpanzees and sooty mangabeys in Africa, in the wild or in captivity, may serve as a zoonotic source of M. leprae. Investigators using chimpanzees and monkeys should be alerted to the possibility of naturally-acquired leprosy.